Helicopter Ben readies for drastic action

After a chaotic few days the market has calmed as it awaits the next round of soothing medicine from the Fed. 100bps is expected now and anything less could see a major sell 0ff. So perhaps its time to recap on what’s happened:

- Global expansion of the money supply by the banking system abetted by loose regulation.

- Financial assets treated as investments.

- Trading on a leverage basis whether in the markets or in property.

- Reliance on capital gain to pay off debts.

- Creation of an asset bubble in property and stocks.

- New financial products promising spectacular gains.

A quick recap:

- Asset prices can go no higher as the mathematics of compound interest and cashflow catches up.

- The first domino falls as the sub-prime market starts to fall.

- Property finally turns and heads south in the US.

- Debts over run equity in houses.

- Spirals into derivative products causing a more widespread reaction.

- First reaction from Fed.

- Banks start to revalue (mark to market) loans.

- First run on a bank: Northern Rock fails.

- UK nationalises Northern Rock.

- General deleveraging starts as contagion spreads.

- Banks review lending and fringe financing companies fail.

- Rogue traders appear.

- Central banks provide copious amounts of liquidity.

- Fed cuts rates heavily and provides open lending to all.

- $ collapses and commodities explode as safe haven.

- Second run on an investment bank: Bear Stearns fails.

- Fed sort of nationalises Bear Stearns but gives it to JP Morgan under guarantee.

- Financial system on the verge of complete collapse.

So what now?

Well the Fed has studied the 1930s depression very carefully and realises that systemic bank failure is simply not an option. Yes shareholders will lose most of their money but that’s the risk with equity. The lines of credit and liquidity must be kept open and depositors must be kept afloat. If necessary banks in trouble will be taken over or have to merge.

It’s safe to say they will do whatever it takes, regardless of the cost. The clean up can come later but for now this is mainly about preserving confidence in the system.

How it pans out is impossible to predict but i wouldn’t want to own any banking stocks.

Markets Routed as Fed tries to hose down Fire

So JPMorgan picks up Bear Stearns for $2…..yes $2…not $20 as on Friday. The fed cuts the discount rate 0.25% which actually is neither here nor there.

The markets rallied initially on some short covering but the market is now in full blown meltdown.

Even Goldman Sachs has reported a write down. Only $3bln which is chump change for them but it shows how this contagion is spreading far and wide.

This is like a game of dominoes now and the central bankers globally need to pull every trick out of the bag to prevent a complete collapse in global banking stocks and general equities.

I would imagine there will be some concerted intervention either in currency markets or in the interest rate markets. This isn’t just a US problem because it will start spreading soon.

This is a very serious situation.

Air New Zealand: Sweatshop in the Sky

Big story out today about Air New Zealand and the rates they are paying their Chinese cabin crew. Shanghai based crew flying on the Shanghai-Auckland route, alongside NZ cabin crew, are being paid less than the NZ minimum wage.

This is nothing short of disgraceful and ANZ will get a deserved roasting in the media. Given that they are majority owned by the Government one can expect a serious review of policy.  But it raises some serious issues: where should the line be drawn?

What about staff working locally on the ground? I would say they are in a local designation and so should be paid local rates but the cabin staff are working in an international space and should be paid the same rates as their NZ based counterparts.

Whilst this issue seems clear cut and a PR fiasco for ANZ, how the international labour market works is not so clear. We send manufacturing offshore, an issue that rankles with many,  in order to take advantage of cheaper labour and other costs. So one could argue that ANZ should be employing as many Chinese cabin staff as possible as their labour is cheaper.

One could also take the argument that working for ANZ is a great opportunity even with the local rates of pay and as the local Chinese airline market expands, as it surely will do, then pay levels will rise as competition kicks in.

The internationalisation of labour is going to bring some interesting issues to the surface as well as unexpected consequences. Previously we have had huge barriers to the movement of labour but with the EU expanding and both China and India developing huge domestic markets, the door will be opened wider to a freer and more efficient labour market.

We’ve had the polish plumber in London so how about the Chinese electrician in New Zealand.

As Ben says “welcome to the global village”.

Fed bail out continues: Bear Stearns throws in the towel

Bear Stearns finally ran up the white flag today and was forced to seek funds from JP Morgan for 28 days. These loans have been underwritten by the Fed essentially preventing Bear Stearns going under.

This was the moment of truth for the Fed. They blinked.

Now they have underwritten the US banking system they will have no choice but to support any institution that experiences similar problems. On one hand this is a prudent move as the implications of a bank failure are very serious but the sad fact is that in order for the market to recover from this era of cheap and funny money is to allow failure to occur.

So the taxpayer can now expect to pick up the tab for this party. It will be interesting to see if this spreads outwards from the US as the credit markets simply disintegrate.

Expect more official action next week probably involving currencies as well.

Liquidity concerns: How safe is your money?

Yesterday the New Zealand arm of the Dutch giant, ING, suspended withdrawals from 2 of its funds affecting some 8000 investors. The 2 funds were invested mainly in credit securities and were down over 20%-25% over the last year.

So nothing new there except the suspension of withdrawals from the fund. Now we’ve seen this already in the banking sector when Northern Rock closed its doors to depositors. Last month Scottish Equitable told 129,000 investors that they could not access funds for at least a year. Its familiar and sad story.

What’s the world coming to when you savings or cash is not safe.  Well maybe we’ve got too comfortable with our present financial arrangements. Have you ever met a poor investment banker? Well probably not. The last 15 years has seen a phenomenal rise in the idea of money as an asset class itself. The ability of banks to create money via debt and ply the financial system with leverage has led to a new type of investing. The ability to create money out of nothing is how markets have grown to the size they are now. It’s not a zero sum game as long as the supply of money and leverage keeps increasing. No one embodies this more than Stephen Schwarzman of Blackstone. Just as George Soros and Michael Milken of previous years, he will be known as the man who made the most of the situation at the time.

What we are witnessing now is the de-leverage when all that new money goes poof! and people look around to see where the security or asset is and find it’s more of the same. Round and round it goes until it simply disappears (money is destroyed) or an asset is finally found to be sold, usually at an extremely low price.

So its pays to be sensible here. Check your savings and investments. Make sure you understand what type of access you have to them and under what terms.

Man the Pumps: Central Banks run up the white flag

With rumours continuing to circle around main street financial institutions in trouble, the Fed along with other central banks piled in another $200bln worth of liquidity in a vain hope to stem the tide. It certainly worked sparking a massive rally in the US market which was looking very weak indeed.

I wrote 6 weeks ago that the Fed would have no option other than to underwrite the whole financial system. This is exactly what they are doing. The worrying aspect of this approach is that it leads the market to depend on continuing liquidity to provide confidence and prevent what would be happening without intervention, namely a full scale rout with several institutions going under.

This creates extreme moral hazard. Even though many financial institutions have clearly acted irresponsibly and in some cases in other ways, they will not be allowed to fail unless a “deal” is worked out where they will be “acquired” quietly for a nominal sum and so the system stays solidly in place and the illusion is maintained.

F.William Engdahl lays out his thoughts on the origins of this mess. It’s focus is the US over the last 100 years and is interesting to read though he makes some strong accusations about the actions of certain people.  The extent to which small cliques have organised and run the financial system is open to questions but there is no doubt that the US prevailed at Bretton Woods on the strength of pure self-interest.

So what now? Well I would say more of the same. But gravity is a powerful force and its hard to imagine these markets not falling further and more de-leveraging taking place in credit and carry trades. I’ll discuss shortly what a new global currency system might look like because the current one is about to explode.